Hi Chri$, I'm not using a book or any predetermined starting positions for my tournament. The conditions for my tournament are specified in post #1 in the thread:
http://talkchess.com/forum/viewtopic.ph ... w=&start=0
40 moves in 5 minutes, repeating
Round Robin
Hash=512
Ponder off
No Book
All Tablebases on SSD
Syzgy bases are 6-piece, Gaviota 5-piece.
Threads=2, no Hyperthreading.
All are 64 bit SSE4.2 engines
Despite the lack of a book, there are a decent variety of openings being played, as can be seen in the PGN link. Even more variety than what is listed in the PGN can be seen if the PGN is loaded into SCID for ECO-classification using the SCID ECO "letter" extensions.
UPDATE: SF-DD-Gaviota still in #2
1440 games
PGN link:
https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_746527
12/24/2013 1:17:40 AM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy : 39 26 26 288 56.2 % -4 58.3 %
2 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota : 17 26 26 288 52.8 % -2 59.0 %
3 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921 : 15 25 25 288 52.4 % -2 61.1 %
4 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota : 9 24 24 288 51.4 % -1 63.9 %
5 Komodo6-64bit : 7 26 26 288 51.0 % -1 58.3 %
6 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 4 26 26 288 50.7 % -0 59.0 %
7 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 1 27 27 288 50.2 % -0 53.8 %
8 Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 0 26 26 288 50.0 % 0 59.0 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota : -33 25 25 288 44.8 % 4 60.4 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -60 27 27 288 40.5 % 7 55.2 %
Individual statistics:
1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 39 288 (+ 78,=168,- 42), 56.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 11,= 19,- 2), 64.1 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 6,= 25,- 1), 57.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 5,= 21,- 6), 48.4 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 11,= 13,- 8), 54.7 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 8,= 15,- 9), 48.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 6,= 23,- 3), 54.7 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 13,= 16,- 3), 65.6 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 9,= 18,- 5), 56.2 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 9,= 18,- 5), 56.2 %
2 Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 17 288 (+ 67,=170,- 51), 52.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 11,= 17,- 4), 60.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 5,= 18,- 9), 43.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 11,= 16,- 5), 59.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 7,= 24,- 1), 59.4 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 4,= 24,- 4), 50.0 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 3,= 24,- 5), 46.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 9,= 17,- 6), 54.7 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 10,= 14,- 8), 53.1 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 7,= 16,- 9), 46.9 %
3 Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 15 288 (+ 63,=176,- 49), 52.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 8,= 20,- 4), 56.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 9,= 15,- 8), 51.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 9,= 18,- 5), 56.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 11,= 12,- 9), 53.1 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 6,= 25,- 1), 57.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 5,= 21,- 6), 48.4 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 5,= 18,- 9), 43.8 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 5,= 24,- 3), 53.1 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 5,= 23,- 4), 51.6 %
4 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 9 288 (+ 56,=184,- 48), 51.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 4,= 27,- 1), 54.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 3,= 23,- 6), 45.3 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 8,= 24,- 0), 62.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 7,= 21,- 4), 54.7 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 6,= 18,- 8), 46.9 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 6,= 21,- 5), 51.6 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 10,= 17,- 5), 57.8 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 6,= 17,- 9), 45.3 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 6,= 16,- 10), 43.8 %
5 Komodo6-64bit : 7 288 (+ 63,=168,- 57), 51.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 8,= 20,- 4), 56.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 5,= 18,- 9), 43.8 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 13,= 16,- 3), 65.6 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 4,= 19,- 9), 42.2 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 9,= 17,- 6), 54.7 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 4,= 23,- 5), 48.4 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 10,= 16,- 6), 56.2 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 1,= 23,- 8), 39.1 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 9,= 16,- 7), 53.1 %
6 Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None: 4 288 (+ 61,=170,- 57), 50.7 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 12,= 16,- 4), 62.5 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 6,= 21,- 5), 51.6 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 9,= 18,- 5), 56.2 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 5,= 21,- 6), 48.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 9,= 12,- 11), 46.9 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 4,= 21,- 7), 45.3 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 6,= 18,- 8), 46.9 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 1,= 24,- 7), 40.6 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 9,= 19,- 4), 57.8 %
7 Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 1 288 (+ 67,=155,- 66), 50.2 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 7,= 21,- 4), 54.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 3,= 16,- 13), 34.4 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 12,= 11,- 9), 54.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 8,= 18,- 6), 53.1 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 7,= 17,- 8), 48.4 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 9,= 18,- 5), 56.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 5,= 17,- 10), 42.2 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 8,= 14,- 10), 46.9 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 8,= 23,- 1), 60.9 %
8 Stockfish_DD_64_modern: 0 288 (+ 59,=170,- 59), 50.0 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 8,= 19,- 5), 54.7 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 8,= 13,- 11), 45.3 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 10,= 16,- 6), 56.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 6,= 21,- 5), 51.6 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 1,= 25,- 6), 42.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 8,= 18,- 6), 53.1 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 8,= 17,- 7), 51.6 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 4,= 24,- 4), 50.0 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 6,= 17,- 9), 45.3 %
9 Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: -33 288 (+ 42,=174,- 72), 44.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 2,= 19,- 11), 35.9 %
Houdini_3_Pro-None : 32 (+ 14,= 15,- 3), 67.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 4,= 16,- 12), 37.5 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 5,= 19,- 8), 45.3 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 4,= 20,- 8), 43.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 1,= 27,- 4), 45.3 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 4,= 21,- 7), 45.3 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 4,= 17,- 11), 39.1 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 4,= 20,- 8), 43.8 %
10 Houdini_3_Pro-None : -60 288 (+ 37,=159,- 92), 40.5 %
Houdini_3_Pro_x64-Gaviota: 32 (+ 3,= 15,- 14), 32.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Syzygy: 32 (+ 1,= 25,- 6), 42.2 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-None : 32 (+ 5,= 18,- 9), 43.8 %
Stockfish_DD_64_modern : 32 (+ 6,= 16,- 10), 43.8 %
Stockfish_DD_Syzygy_13112921: 32 (+ 5,= 18,- 9), 43.8 %
Houdini_4_Pro_x64B-Gaviota: 32 (+ 0,= 24,- 8), 37.5 %
Komodo-TCEC-64bit : 32 (+ 9,= 11,- 12), 45.3 %
Stockfish-DD-64-PA_Gaviota: 32 (+ 5,= 16,- 11), 40.6 %
Komodo6-64bit : 32 (+ 3,= 16,- 13), 34.4 %